TD Bank Financial Group
Home  |  Search  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy and Security
  
   About TDBFG   Investor Relations   Economics   Careers   Corporate Responsibility   To Our Customers 
   Analysis      About TD Economics  


Data Commentaries

CANADIAN GDP STUCK IN AN EXPORT DRIVEN RUT

August 29, 2008

  • Negligible economic growth of 0.3% in Q2 after revised 0.8% decline in Q1
  • Exports continue to subtract from growth, offset by a rebound in business inventories
  • Domestic demand cooling

After shrinking by 0.8% annualized (revised down from -0.3% previously) in the first quarter, the Canadian economy managed to skirt the technical definition of a recession by growing a modest 0.3%. Unfortunately, there wasn’t much else good we could find to say about it. The Canadian economy is still smaller than it was in the fourth quarter of 2007 and only 0.7% ahead of its position a full year ago. Once again, the weakness was concentrated firmly in the export sector, which subtracted over 2 percentage points from total GDP growth in the quarter. The domestic side of the economy maintained some strength with personal consumption growing by 2.4% and final domestic demand maintaining a pace above 2.0%.

As if to add insult to injury, the Canadian GDP report arrives on the heals of a resounding 3.3% increase in U.S. GDP in the same time period. Canadians who have been hearing of the impending U.S. doom for much of the last year must be shaking their heads – how could we be doing so much worse than our counterparts to the south? Keep in mind that a fair amount of the increase in the U.S. is attributable to the economic stimulus checks, which managed to keep personal consumption growth positive. But it is also due to polar opposite results in each country’s trade sectors. Canadian exports, which make up a much larger share of the Canadian economy than in the U.S. (37% vs. 13%) , have fallen in each of the last three quarters, whereas the falling U.S. dollar has increased the competitiveness of U.S. exports, culminating in a 1.7 percentage point contribution to GDP in the second quarter - the mirror opposite of the Canadian position.

While the domestic side of the Canadian economy has continued to outperform the U.S. and this will likely continue through the course of this year, it too will slow from its recent highs. Fed by strong income and employment gains, growth in personal consumption has been running at a pace above 3% for well over the past two years. With job growth slowing and income growth soon to follow, the days of the spendthrift Canadian consumer are quickly coming to a close. Moreover, the Canadian housing market is no longer the driving force it once was and subtracted from economic growth for a second straight quarter. With weakness on the export side to continue through the remainder of this year and the domestic side showing signs of moderating, the Canadian economy is likely to grow at an annual rate below 1%. This will surely be on the mind of the Bank of Canada when they meet next week to make their interest rate decision. While we continue to believe they will keep the overnight rate at 3.0%, we also expect the Bank to acknowledge that the Canadian economy is performing significantly worse than outlined in their latest Monetary Policy Report.

James Marple, Economist
416-982-2557


For the full report in PDF format click here.



Current Publications
Daily Economic Indicators*
Weekly Bottom Line*
Weekly Commodity Price Report*
Global Markets*
Quarterly Commodity Price Report*
Quarterly Economic Forecast*
Long-term Economic Forecast*
Provincial Economic Forecast*
Industrial Outlook*
Monetary Policy Monitor*
Federal & Provincial Budgets

Special Reports
Household Balance Sheet Improves, But Debt Growth Constrains Net Worth*
Back To Balance: What's Next For The U.S. Housing Market?*
The Changing Canadian Workplace*
Signs Of Cooling In Canada's Resale Housing Markets*
Strength In Renovation Spending Running On Borrowed Demand*
Prudential Changes To Canadian Mortgage Insurance Rules*
U.S. Won't Have A Jobless Recovery*
Crude Oil Market Still Facing Massive Glut*
U.S. Consumer Credit & Household Deleveraging*
Gold Prices: Has The Rally Run Out Of Steam?*
Men Fare Worse During Recessions, But What About Recoveries?*
The Global Economy of Tomorrow: Better, Stronger, Faster*
Canadian Housing: First In, First Out, But Where To From Here?*
Why Monthly and Quarterly GDP Can Differ*
An Update On Consumer Insolvency*
Innovation And New Investment Remain Key To Business Success*
U.S. Commercial Real Estate Is A Speed Bump, But Not A Road Block To Recovery*
Possible Economic Impact of H1N1*
A New Normal: Canada's Potential Growth During Recovery And Beyond*
How Will The Great Recession And Its Recovery Compare To The Past?*
Outlook For Canadian Agriculture*
Is The Global Economy Hard-Wired For A Lingering Fed?*
A summary of the Pembina/David Suzuki Foundation paper*
The Coming Era Of Fiscal Restraint*
Economic Recovery To Kick Start Small Businesses*
The Future Cost Of A University Degree*
Resale Housing Outlook*
Real Estate Trends Could Impact Future Path Of Canadian Monetary Policy*
The Impact of Sales Tax Harmonization in Ontario and B.C. on Canadian Inflation*