Investing with Low Volatility – Being the Calm within the Storm

Figure 1 – Large-cap players led on the upside in 2024 and the downside in 2025

Source: FactSet Research Systems Inc. As of Mar 14, 2025.

Low volatility strategies have provided a steady hand amid the market turbulence, reinforcing their role in capital preservation during volatile periods, and ultimately delivering a smoother return experience.  By capturing a portion of the market’s early-year gains while sidestepping the recent downturn, these strategies have demonstrated resilience in navigating today’s unpredictable market conditions.

Low volatility strategies primarily invest in stable, non-cyclical companies. Because these strategies are constructed to have less risk than a cap-weighted benchmark with the goal of providing better risk adjusted returns, low volatility strategies will tend to lag in strong upward moving markets as seen in 2024 but provide capital preservation by limiting participation in market declines.  Low volatility strategies demonstrated resilience during the 2022 drawdown and again in the brief market correction in the third quarter of 2024.  The defensive nature of low volatility is working to the benefit of its investors in 2025 acting as a calm within a volatile storm.  Over the long-term investing cycle, low volatility strategies typically generate much of their relative performance in adverse equity markets.

Figure 1 – Large-cap players led on the upside in 2024 and the downside in 2025

Figure 2 – What to expect in up and down markets for a low volatility investor - An average monthly return comparison

Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P. Data from December 31, 1998 to February 28, 2025

When comparing the year-to-date performance of low volatility strategies to cap-weighted indices globally, it is clear that there has been a shift in sentiment and a move towards a de-risking environment.  Low volatility indices are continuing to deliver positive returns while global cap-weighted indices are negative.  Future market movements will continue to be impacted by the ever-changing tariff landscape.

Figure 3 – Minimum volatility indices are weathering the tariff storm

Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P. Data from December 31, 2024 to March 14, 2025

In 2023, the team at TD Asset Management Inc. (TDAM) published an article on de-risking and the downside protection of low volatility.  Diversification is a critical tool for reducing risk, yet it is often overlooked until market stress highlights its necessity.  Low volatility strategies, by design, have less risk than other equity styles and lower downside correlations. While low volatility is not the top-performing factor all the time, when we average across multiple periods, the low volatility style remains the best alternative for capital preservation and downside portfolio protection within equities, in times of market stress.  

Figure 4 – Style performance during crises – Low volatility, on average, provides more capital preservation 

Note: Average annualized monthly returns refers to the average annualized return over the 94 months spanning the six crises described here.  Source: MSCI, TD Asset Management Inc. As of May 31, 2023.

The ongoing uncertainty surrounding tariffs, both in terms of scope, implementation, and potential escalation, is contributing to increased market volatility.  Historically, such environments have provided an opportunity for low volatility strategies to add value, as they are designed to offer potential downside protection during periods of heightened uncertainty.  As tariffs are announced and the likelihood of the application of global reciprocal tariffs increases, broad markets tend to react sharply negative.  Given their defensive nature, low volatility strategies will typically experience lower downside participation.  

This is exactly what low volatility investors experienced over the two trading days of January 31^st and February 1^st, when the broad Canadian market dropped more than 2% on the U.S. announcement of initial tariff intentions against Canada and Mexico.  Overall, trade tensions and tariff-related disruptions can be detrimental to global growth, but such conditions often reinforce the value of low volatility strategies.

In today’s uncertain market environment, the case for low volatility investing remains compelling.  By prioritizing capital preservation and risk-adjusted returns, these strategies help investors remain disciplined through volatile market cycles.  While they may lag in strong upward-trending markets, their ability to cushion against sharp downturns has historically led to better long-term risk adjusted performance.  With geopolitical shifts, international trade disputes, and economic uncertainty continuing to weigh on investor sentiment, low volatility strategies can be the calm within the storm and serve as an essential tool for managing risk while maintaining equity exposure.  As history has shown, market downturns are inevitable, and having a strategic allocation to low volatility can help investors navigate uncertainty while still participating in long-term growth opportunities.